5th Street Pub – Perrysburg Historical District – Toledo, OH Crust is perfectly authentic, and the toppings are great.
Happy Valentine’s Day from my pizza loving heart to yours! Now, go get your heart shaped pizza.
Earthfare – Center Ridge – Rocky River, OH This pizza has SO MUCH FLAVOR! Barely any sauce but the produce provides the right amount of moisture for your palate. Sadly, Earthfare is closing! Check out what locations are still open so you can get your slice before it’s too late!
Lou Malnati’s – Frozen Prepared – Chicago, IL Yes, this pizza is not from Cleveland, BUT this is still one of the best pies I’ve ever eaten. Fresh in the restaurant, or frozen to keep fresh, this true deep dish pizza has the best pizza sauce I’ve ever eaten. Order yours here.
Costco Pizza – Avon Lake – Avon Lake, OH Nothing to say, other than that Costco Pizza slaps. Always a good pizza for your last minute pizza crave.
Saucy Brew Works – Ohio City – Cleveland, OH Sauce: 7.2Crust: 7.9Balance: 8.4Cheese : 8.3Overall score: 7.9Style: Brick Oven
Citizen Pie – Ohio City – Cleveland, OH Sauce: 8.2Crust: 9.2Balance: 8.7Cheese : 8.1Overall score: 8.55Style: Brick Oven Proportion Scale:Cheese 🧀🧀Sauce 🍅🍅Crust 🥖🥖✅ Clean Plate Club ✅Would eat again ✅
Papa Nick’s Pizza & Pasta – Edgewater – Cleveland, OH Sauce: 7.4Crust: 7.9Balance: 8.4Cheese : 7.6Overall score: 7.8Style: Brick OvenWould eat again ✅–Proportion Scale:Cheese 🧀🧀🧀Sauce 🍅🍅Crust 🥖🥖✅Super filling, would be Clean Plate Club if not so delicious✅
The Wild Goose – Willoughby, OH Sauce: 8.4Crust: 7.7Balance: 9.2Cheese : 7.3Overall score: 8.1Style: Brick Oven Would eat again ✅ Proportion Scale:Cheese 🧀🧀Sauce 🥔 🥔 🥔 🥔Crust 🥖🥖🥖 ✅ would be clean plate club if the flavor wasn’t so rich and delicious ✅
Danny Boy’s Pizza – Rocky River, OH Sauce: 7.2Crust: 6.1Balance: 7.3Cheese : 7.4Overall score: 7Style: Brick Oven Would eat again ✅ Proportion Scale:Cheese 🧀🧀🧀🧀Sauce 🍅🍅🍅Crust 🥖🥖✅Clean Plate Club✅